|
BHARAT……..”The
Development Dilemma”
INDIA
CHALLENGE SERIES – 1
Poor Infrastructure Obstruction in
Development
https://youtu.be/D1d_K-PUqfo
https://youtu.be/mh_beIyXbj4
The chapter argues that
inadequate infrastructure remains a binding constraint on India’s economic and
social development, despite notable advances across sectors. The country’s
growth potential is throttled by gaps in transport networks, power reliability,
water and sanitation services, and digital reach. These deficits are not only
technical; they are rooted in historical legacies, funding shortfalls,
regulatory complexity, skills gaps, corruption, environmental conflicts,
logistical weaknesses, slow technology adoption, and policy instability. The
chapter traces the evolution of India’s infrastructure, diagnoses the systemic
obstacles that slow delivery, assesses the current status across key sectors,
and proposes a multi-pronged reform agenda.
Historically, pre-colonial
India demonstrated sophisticated infrastructure suited to its time-well-laid
trade routes, water management through tanks, stepwells, and canals, and
advanced urban planning visible in Harappa and Mohenjo-Daro. Colonial rule
introduced large-scale railways, ports, telegraph, and canals-significant assets
that nonetheless prioritized extraction and imperial control. Post-independence,
infrastructure was central to nation-building via Five-Year Plans, major dams,
steel plants, and highway programs; the Green Revolution prompted irrigation and
electrification; liberalization in the 1990s unlocked private capital and PPPs,
giving momentum to highways (Golden Quadrilateral), telecom, airports, and urban
metros. Recent initiatives-National Infrastructure Pipeline (NIP), Smart Cities,
Bharatmala, Sagarmala, Digital India, PM Gati Shakti-reflect ambition. Yet the
chapter emphasizes a persistent execution gap.
Systemic challenges are led by
finance. The NIP estimated a need of Rs. 111 lakh crore for 2019-2025, with a
30-40% shortfall. High public debt (~90% of GDP in 2021), bank NPAs (8.6% in
PSBs in 2021), and mixed PPP outcomes constrain investment. New vehicles like
NIIF (~USD 4 billion raised by 2021) and InvITs help but remain insufficient
relative to needs. Funding gaps have slowed or downsized flagship programs
(e.g., Bharatmala, Smart Cities, renewables requiring USD 500 billion by 2030).
Regulatory and bureaucratic
hurdles are equally binding. Land acquisition, multi-agency approvals, and
environmental clearances prolong timelines and raise costs. The Navi Mumbai
International Airport, Mumbai-Ahmedabad High-Speed Rail, and multiple
expressways and corridors faced lengthy land disputes and community
negotiations. Projects like the DFC needed over 30 clearances, while
environmental litigation delayed the Mumbai Coastal Road. PPPs (e.g., Delhi-Gurgaon
Expressway) suffered due to ambiguous contracts and oversight gaps. Large
schemes such as Polavaram have been mired in coordination issues and inter-state
disputes. The chapter calls for predictable, time-bound, single-window
approvals; fair and swift acquisition with robust compensation and
rehabilitation; and better inter-agency project management.
Technical and skill deficits
slow execution and compromise quality. Specialized capabilities-tunneling for
metros, advanced highway engineering, smart city systems, and renewable O&M-are
in short supply. Projects from Bengaluru and Kolkata metros to Bharatmala roads,
solar parks like Rewa, and airport builds such as Mopa reported delays linked to
a shortage of trained personnel. Root causes include education-industry
mismatch, brain drain, and training systems lagging technological change.
Governance weaknesses amplify
delays and costs. The chapter cites the 2010 Commonwealth Games, Sardar Sarovar,
the Mumbai Monorail, NHDP packages, and Ganga Action Plan to illustrate how
corruption, opaque tenders, and red tape inflate costs-by 20-30% according to
World Bank estimates-and undermine quality and trust. Strengthened oversight,
transparent procurement, and digital monitoring are emphasized.
Environmental activism has
altered the trajectory of several large projects Sterlite Copper (closure),
Vedanta’s Niyamgiri mining (halted after Gram Sabha votes), Subansiri dam,
Mumbai Coastal Road, POSCO steel plant, and the bullet train’s mangrove impacts.
The chapter does not dismiss activism; it urges integrating rigorous EIAs,
consent, mitigation, biodiversity offsets, and fair resettlement early in
planning to balance growth with sustainability and avoid protracted litigation.
India’s logistics
ecosystem-ranked 44th in the World Bank’s LPI (2018)-adds to costs and execution
risks. Logistics consumes 13-14% of GDP versus 8-10% in peers. The Golden
Quadrilateral faced extended delays; Sagarmala is constrained by weak
port-hinterland links and warehousing; DMIC has suffered from phased support
infrastructure and approvals; North-East projects are slowed by terrain and
access; DFC timelines and costs ballooned; even metro expansions struggle with
moving oversized equipment. Fragmentation, limited multimodality, and weak cold
chain add to inefficiency.
Slow technology adoption
further depresses productivity-construction productivity is 20-25% below global
averages. Highways rely on conventional materials; railway signalling upgrades
lag; smart city integration (traffic, grids, waste) has been slow, with only a
quarter of proposed solutions timely as of 2019; BIM and prefabrication remain
underused; water programs like Namami Gange struggled to complete sewage
treatment capacity and real-time monitoring. The chapter urges mainstreaming
modern materials, digital twins, automation, and smart systems.
Policy instability compounds
risks. MoSPI data show widespread time and cost overruns; the World Bank links
policy uncertainty to reductions in infrastructure investment. The Mumbai Metro
Line 3 car-shed dispute, POSCO’s exit, Teesta hydro delays, Navi Mumbai
Airport’s shifting timelines, and the stop-go pattern of the Ganga Action Plan
exemplify the cost of political oscillation.
The sectoral snapshot
underscores these themes:
i. Railways: With 67,000 km, they remain vital but congested on trunk
routes, run on aging assets, and carry a high operating ratio (~98.4% in
2021-22). Safety incidents persist; advanced signalling coverage is limited;
electrification is progressing but not complete. DFCs are intended to decongest
and shift freight but have faced delays and overruns. Integrating suburban,
metro, and intercity systems and modernizing stations is ongoing yet slow.
ii. Roads and surface
transport: India’s 6.3 million km network bears quality deficits; around 40%
of rural roads are poor. Urban congestion is severe; India accounts for over 11%
of global road fatalities, with more than 150,000 deaths in 2019. National
highways are just 2% of length but carry 40% of traffic, creating bottlenecks.
Funding constraints, environmental impacts, and lagging ITS adoption persist.
iii. Civil aviation:
Among the fastest-growing markets, with 400+ airports, but major hubs are near
or over capacity. UDAN improves regional connectivity slowly. Airlines face high
ATF taxes, thin margins, and debt (Jet’s collapse, Air India’s legacy debt),
compounded by pilot shortages and slower tech uptake. Sustainability measures
lag global trends.
iv. Inland waterways:
With ancient roots and institutional support (IWAI, National Waterways, Jal Marg
Vikas on NW-1), the mode remains underutilized due to sedimentation, limited
year-round navigability, inadequate port facilities, and maintenance
underfunding. Sagarmala aims to modernize ports and connectivity but must fix
hinterland links and logistics nodes.
v. Water and sanitation:
Access has risen (91% basic drinking water), but quality is uneven, with
fluoride and arsenic exposure in parts of eastern and western India, groundwater
depletion, and aging urban networks. Sanitation improved under Swachh Bharat
(65% improved sanitation; toilets built at scale), yet usage gaps, sewage
treatment deficiencies (only about 30% of sewage treated), and waste management
shortfalls remain.
vi. Power: Installed
capacity reached 428.6 GW, but thermal PLFs hover around 55-60%. Peak demand hit
243 GW in 2024, with regional shortages of 10-12 GW in summer. An energy
shortfall of about 0.8% masks acute local distress driven by coal logistics,
weather, and grid constraints. DISCOM debts and 18–20% T&D losses in some states
undermine viability. Integration of intermittent renewables requires storage,
grid modernization, and market design. Government programs (Saubhagya, DDUGJY,
UDAY, RDSS, Green Energy Corridors, Solar Mission) have expanded access and
capacity, but structural reforms are still needed.
The reform agenda advanced in
the chapter is comprehensive. On finance, expand public outlays, deepen PPPs
with clear risk-sharing, scale NIIF / InvITs / municipal bonds, and restore
DISCOM health through cost-reflective tariffs, timely subsidies, and AT&C loss
reduction. On governance, establish single-window, time-bound clearances;
standardize contracts; strengthen independent oversight and audit; publish
real-time dashboards (leveraging PM Gati Shakti) for transparency. On land and
environment, institutionalize swift acquisition with fair compensation and
rehabilitation, robust EIAs, and community participation to reduce litigation.
On capability, align education with industry needs, expand vocational and
sector-specific training, and incentivize talent retention. On technology,
mainstream BIM, prefabrication, smart signalling, ITS, smart grids, and
real-time water/waste systems; deploy AI for demand forecasting and project
monitoring.
—————————————————-
About The Article
This article is the extract of one of the chapter of the best-selling book on
Indian Macro-Economics, titled…. Bharat……..” The Development Dilemma”
authored by CA Anil Kumar Jain.
“This book is a must-read for
every aware and enlightened citizen. It presents an in-depth analysis of the
challenges faced by an emerging India and offers innovative suggestions and
practical solutions to overcome them, paving the way for our nation to attain
the esteemed position of Vishwaguru in the near future.”
The book is available at
Amazon, Flipkart, Google Play Books and Ahimsa Foundation (WhatsApp Your Request –
9810046108).
|
